Fernando Mendoza lifted the Heisman Trophy this weekend, and the moment landed with extra meaning in South Florida. The quarterback grew up a half-mile from the University of Miami campus, played at Christopher Columbus High School, attended UM camps and wanted a shot in Coral Gables. Miami never gave him one that matched his goals, so he built his path somewhere else.
Mendoza carried a low recruiting profile coming out of Columbus, and he later pointed to the pandemic as a major reason. His junior year coincided with COVID disruptions, which limited exposure and slowed his momentum. Miami recruits quarterbacks like a national brand, and Mendoza sat outside that early spotlight.
Yale offered Mendoza first, and he committed to the Ivy League school before an FBS opportunity arrived late. In February 2022, the agreement with Yale didn’t include scholarship aid, which kept the door open. Cal offensive coordinator Bill Musgrave visited Miami, offered a full scholarship and flipped the decision in short order.
Mendoza wanted Miami, but Miami didn’t recruit him. He also said Miami already had “all the national recruits and quarterbacks they wanted,” a blunt summary of how he read the board during his senior year. A Miami Herald story in October 2024 added the detail Miami fans fixate on now: when Mendoza asked about interest, he heard a walk-on message. He said the response “lit a fire.”
The transfer portal offered Miami a second swing, and the fit looked obvious on paper: hometown ties, size, production, maturity. Mendoza entered the portal Dec. 11, 2024, with Miami expected to shop for a quarterback after Cam Ward moved toward the NFL.
Indiana won that race. Mendoza picked the Hoosiers over Miami and Georgia for his commitment. From there, Mendoza turned a detour into a destination, then turned a destination into hardware.
Mendoza never went to Miami for one core reason: Miami never treated him like a scholarship quarterback, then lost in the portal when his options widened.
Leave a Reply